Beartown Peaches N Cream: Delicious Ice Cream in Painted Post, NY

Top categories (Cream / Specialty Sundaes / Specialtyshakes / Others)
Most orders: ₫

Welcome to Beartown Peaches N Cream, a delightful ice cream shop nestled at 5 Beartown Rd in Painted Post, NY. This charming local gem is not just an ice cream destination; it’s an experience steeped in nostalgia and community warmth. With a legacy that spans generations, it remains a beloved spot for locals and visitors alike.

As you approach the shop, the bold sign beckons with promises of creamy indulgence. The casual, inviting atmosphere makes it a perfect stop for families, whether you're just passing through or looking to satisfy a sweet tooth after a day of exploring the area. While standing in line, you’ll get a sense of the friendly vibe cultivated by the warm staff, who are always ready to assist you in crafting the perfect treat.

At Beartown, the menu is a treasure trove of delicious options. You can indulge in their Specialty Sundaes like the Andes and Reese's Pieces, each generously layered to create a symphony of flavors. If you’re in the mood for something playful, the Dirt & Worms sundae is sure to impress with its whimsical mix of fudge and gummy worms. For a classic twist, don’t miss the Banana Split or the seasonal favorite, Caramel Apple.

The Specialty Shakes are another must-try, with options like Oreo Crazy and Mochacchino bringing rich, invigorating flavors to your cup. Reviews highlight the thick, creamy texture of the shakes, which are not overly sweet, making them the ideal treat to cool off on a hot summer day.

Many satisfied customers rave about the generous portions and phenomenal value. Aaron R recalls fond memories visiting with family, while Alyssa Puhacz emphasizes how her family always brings out-of-town visitors to experience the unique flavor of Perry’s ice cream served here. Abhilash Yerra was pleasantly surprised by the flavors available, praising the opportunity to sample up to three before making a decision—perfect for those who enjoy exploring new tastes!

For those who prioritize dietary options, Beartown has you covered with a variety of flavors including dairy-free choices. Customers like Lake Kubilius appreciate the vegan flavors alongside the classic options, underscoring the shop’s commitment to catering to all sweet tooth cravings.

In every scoop, you can expect a burst of joy and a reminder of simpler, carefree times. Beartown Peaches N Cream is not merely an ice cream shop; it's a community landmark where memories are made one delicious treat at a time. So, whether you are a lifelong patron or a newcomer, be sure to stop by, grab a cone, and create your own flavors of nostalgia today!

Has wheelchair-accessible car park
Has wheelchair-accessible entrance

On-site services available
Offers takeaway
No delivery
No dine-in
No same-day delivery

Accepts credit cards

Aaron R

08/12/2025

15 or so years ago used to stop here. Frequently when my grandparents were alive and lived just up the road Got the chance to bring my son today as we will in Southern pa

Alyssa Puhacz

26/11/2025

We take all of our out-of-town visitors here. They serve Perry’s ice cream and more. They have huge portions and low prices! Highly recommend.

Abhilash Yerra

25/11/2025

Honestly was surprised by the flavors. It was thick and not too sweet and sizes of the scoops were massive. The lady at the front gave pretty good suggestions and you can sample up to 3 flavors. Would love to visiting again soon and try out other flavors

Jeffrey Liu

13/11/2025

Peaches N Cream is a local institution. Huge menu, warm vibe, and friendly people. Can’t decide? Ask Dani for recommendations! She’ll build you something phenomenal you never knew you needed. ~ My recent obsessions here: 1. Kahlua Almond Amaretto 2. Bittersweet Symphony 3. Praline Turtle 4. Caramel with coffee/toffee 5. Super Berry Açaí 6. Apple Cider Donut Sundae

R K

09/11/2025

Evening Treat at Beartown Peaches & Cream – A Soft Serve Sampler in Painted Post, NY Stopped by Beartown Peaches & Cream in Painted Post, NY, for a quick ice cream fix. The place has that nostalgic roadside charm, with a big, bold sign and a casual walk-up window that makes it feel like summer even on cooler evenings. I decided to try their soft serve chocolate and espresso coffee swirl, served in a cup with a fun upside-down cone stuck on top—definitely a playful presentation that made for a great photo-op. As for the flavor, it was okay but didn’t quite hit the mark for me. The chocolate was smooth but very mild, and the espresso flavor was quite faint—almost unnoticeable. I was hoping for a stronger coffee punch, especially since espresso usually has a bold profile. The texture of the soft serve was creamy and pleasant, but the overall taste didn’t wow me. That said, I have a feeling their hard ice cream options might be stronger in flavor and worth coming back for. This visit felt more like a casual stop than a standout ice cream experience, but the setting is friendly and inviting. If you’re passing through and want something sweet, it’s still worth checking out—just maybe skip the soft serve and try the scoops instead!

EJ B

11/10/2025

This is the best value for an ice cream scoop I've ever gotten. So many flavors to choose from and the ice cream is good. Very good! They know how to set you up for success. If you get a cone with 3 or more scoops on a really hot day they still give you a cup to manage it all.

Lake Kubilius

01/09/2025

Fantastic place to stop and cool down from the summer heat. Has a few vegan flavors, including a rotating Dole Whip soft serve flavor. Portions run huge, and the pricing is extremely reasonable. Try it!

Your insights help other diners decide. We’ll keep your email private. Required fields are marked *